As for the life of Pocahontas, the whole myth about her and John Smith was just that, something I knew before this. May 18, Ben Myers rated it really liked it Shelves: This not only brings these historical characters to life, it creates a picture of how the English and Powhatans saw each other, themselves, and their destinies. Though not “royal” in one sense because her mother was woman in the lower social order, Pocahontas was recognized by her father. In fact, it was a well-documented book that honestly looked at what happened.

Pocahontas and the Powhatan Dilemma Review. She later marries John Rolfe an English man who experience much of the reverse colonization. Pocahontas’s life is here shown as a road map to Native American strategies of defiance exercised in the face of overwhelming odds and in the hope for a semblance of independence worth the name. Townsend does conjecture a lot about what the historical players likely thought and felt, but I found her convincing. I thought it was going to be a book about all the wonderful things Pocahontas and the Native Americans did, and all the awful things the Europeans did to them.

The English thinking was that the Indians would be happy and willing to learn from them, hopefully eventually paying tribute to the English king. Be the first to ask a question about Pocahontas and the Powhatan Dilemma.

However, it was a satisfying ending and a very enjoyable book. They myth of Pochontas is to pervasive that it was wonderful to see the real person behind the story – at least as much as we could see.

Pocahontas and the Powhatan Dilemma: The American Portraits Series

I had to read this pocahkntas my History of Women class, and I found this to be a very interesting tale and a new perspective on Pocahontas and her people. Pocahontas would become very ill around the time the Rolfe family was ready to head back to Virginia.

Over time many English were sent to live with natives to learn their culture anx a native would be sent with the English. I highly recommend this book–I read it in two days because it was fascinating and made clear what is known and what can be reasonably speculated, though our course syllabus spread the reading out over a week.


John Smith comes into play in when the English begin to prepare for the Virginia campaign. I really enjoyed this book and would recommend. I appreciated the details they added with the old writing style but there were just so many I forgot what story I was reading when they popped up; and they popped up A LOT.

Pocahontas and the Powhatan Dilemma Review Essay Example for Free – Sample words

The term we learned in class for this is recolonization. I pocahintas the Disney version if I’m going to get the watered down “true story”.

We also learn that within the native culture of the Powhatan that there chiefs do not come from the next up son, but from marriage of the daughters. The author of this book discussed this.

thesis of pocahontas and the powhatan dilemma

I surprised myself by enjoying this book. The author tells us that the native were not completely different from the Europeans just simply behind the times.

Pocahontas and the Powhatan Dilemma Review Essay

This very readable book’s strengths lay in its not imagining Pocahontas as she is “traditionally” imagined in American minds and certainly not in Disney minds. Before her marriage though Pocahontas was kidnapped one of the main characters they looked over her kidnapping was Sir Thomas Dale who was the first Marshall of Pohatan.

Jun 23, Matthew Brehm rated it it was amazing.

thesis of pocahontas and the powhatan dilemma

I really enjoyed this book. I learned that much of what we were taught or told of her in are childhood was wrong.

It is thessi unrealistic to believe the Native Americans were only supplicant admirers of English culture and technology. Aug 01, Barbara Stevens rated it really liked it. One of the things that has always caused me to think was why the colonization of North America resulted in the US being a more prosperous country, while the colonization of Central and South Pocahotas resulted in many les I surprised myself by enjoying this book.


All in all, the story was still interesting enough to read and I didn’t dislike it as much as I’ve disliked other books I’ve read. The most notable was Pocahontas herself was sent with the English to learn their language and lifestyle.

Despite the minimal records of the things Pocahontas said and did, and in spite of the fact that most of the records that do exist are unreliable, To I read this for my Survey hhesis American History class at Oklahoma State University under Dr.

An easier task is postulating the motivations of her father Powhatan, whose marriage alliances and assimilation of neighboring tribes into his control shows his astute political sense.

It was interesting to read how the English took some of thesjs Indians to England to learn the language, so they could return and be translators.

thesis of pocahontas and the powhatan dilemma

I was sadly mistaken. Why so many quotes? This first part of the book it explains the culture of the Powhatan and how they are laid out. But most importantly if you were ever curious to know more about Pocahontas, this book is a great place to start and dispel the Disney myths. After the landing John Smith gets taken by the Powhatan and convince them not to kill him by way of trade. The plans of the English and John Smith was to: It not only explored so many facets of this muddled history but gave new insight into Pocahontas and numerous others; their thoughts, feelings, beliefs, and motives.