What are the consequences? When Eilis asks why she is being given the best room, Mrs. This was where Eilis had come with Rose and her brothers and her parents when they were children, but she had not been there for years nor thought about it. See also our VCE workbook for students: She is already married to Tony, so things cannot work for both. And, of course, she does not tell anyone in Ireland about her marriage.

Thank you in advance My writing style is rather simple – please let me know if this would affect my results at the end of the year. Are these people you would want to meet? It is not that she does not have her own desires. Her solution to homesickness works. Kehoe could have used her, the only lodger who did not seem to know why Miss Keegan had left. But as we also know, Jack soon cherishes his independence. She avoids acting to avoid damaging them.

Characterisation is the way in which the author constructs the characters, to position the reader to respond. On the other hand, the ideas and values the text explores also exist outside the world of the text. Furthermore, Tony and his family offer her the chance to start anew in America. In order to spare Eilis the sorrow and guilt esay with her return, the mother seeks to downplay the enormity of their separation. Earlier, of course, Brooklyn and her life there seemed unreal.

I think it’d be best to have longer quotes – they’d provide stronger support brooklun your claims. If she woke in the night, or found time going slowly at work, she went over it all again blaming Mrs.

Search the forums now!

Foreshadowing a renewed cycle of loneliness and isolation, Eilis knows now just what she must forgo because of her perhaps rather hasty commitment to Tony.


Whilst Brooklyn represents the necessity of a new home esay obligation it is once again divided by the fact that it necessarily represents what she has lost: There was something helpless about him as he stood there; his willingness to be happy, his eagerness she saw, made him oddly vulnerable.

Coincidentally, too, the lugubrious winter weather reflects her sense of gloominess. And Diana has refused to stay in the basement on her own. No matter what she dreamed about, no matter how bad she felt, she had no choice, she knew, but to put it all swiftly out of her mind. Whilst her mother continues to symbolise absence and the tug of her Irish roots, Eilis also forges a homely relationship with Tony Fiorello and his surrogate family that will only ever be a substitute.

Vxe about her feelings suggests that her marriage to Tony will be fulfilling to her. Toibin exploits this by giving us so little of Eilis besides her seeming pliability. The letters are all that remain between mother and daughter as an ambiguous marker of both loss and connection; one forever unaware of just how much the other knows, or deliberately forgets. Miss McAdam, another lodger, sits Eilis down and gives her an alternate explanation for Eilis ending in the room.


However, it also becomes a place that provides Eilis with the opportunity to renew herself and carve an independent future without the strong shadows cast by her family. As they drove through Blackwater village she almost pointed out the places she knew, such as Mrs.

Kehoe had genuinely given her the otibin out of pure generosity and unlikely also that Miss McAdam and the others really did not mind this and had merely wanted to warn her about the man who had followed Miss Keegan so that she would be careful. Evidently, Enniscorthy represents many of the positive attributes of home such as comfort, security and familiarity, but brkoklyn is also a place that divides Eilis from herself in many subtle ways.


Brooklyn by Colm Toibin

For each of the main characters write a summary of important information such as: The answer was that there was no answer, that nothing she could do would be right. She longs for her Irish home and the familiar.

However, despite beginning to settle into Brooklyn, returning to Ireland brings back the strangeness of Brooklyn for Eilis. Toibin’s portrayal of Eilis’ colj illustrates one’s ability to find strengths in time of hardship. Describe five to ten differences between Brooklyn and Ireland during the s. She is already married to Toigin, so things cannot work for both.

As KfC and John Self have pointed out, she tends to take the path of least resistance with almost no regard for who is pushing her. Consequently, the relationship with Tony Fiorello, whom she meets at the Parish Church dance, is pivotal to her transformation. Again, Toibin returns to earlier imagery. She was nobody here. Eilis is a light character.

brooklyn colm toibin essay vce

She is too often what Rose, her mother, Mrs. Why do you think Eilis is hesitant in her feelings? Values provide common ground for everyday decisions about right and wrong behaviour.

brooklyn colm toibin essay vce